Clawed
Friday, October 29th, 2010The more you think about the 106th World Series, the more you have to believe that the Texas Rangers are not simply snake bit, they’re actually over matched — or worse: that the real contest to see who’s the best in baseball has already taken place. And the Phillies lost. Fans of the American League will bitterly deny this, arguing that we have yet to see the real Rangers’ line-up, that Cliff Lee will assuredly return to form, that the Lone Stars’ two, three and four hitters will find their rhythm in Arlington. Not a few Texas fans are blaming manager Ron Washington for the flame-out, arguing that he could have kept the Giants close in last night’s 9-0 blowout if he had brought uber closer Neftali Perez in to pitch the 8th. The criticism’s fair, Lookout Landing says, but bringing in Feliz probably wouldn’t have changed the game’s outcome. That true; but the point of the criticism has little to do with Washington’s decision in the eighth inning of last night’s game and more to do with his decision making for the entire series. Which has been questionable.
Washington failed to fill out a line-up capable of hitting in an N.L. pitcher’s park, where long balls fall onto the warning track and hits to the right-center and left-center alleys never die. David Murphy (who has little no power) and Matt Treanor (who is a average poor hitter in the best of times) are fine players who are important pieces in a 162 game season (when regulars have to be rested), but they have no business starting in a seven game do-or-die series for all the marbles — particularly when Vlad Guerrero and Bengie Molina have played a lifetime of games in pressure situations against tough competition. Murphy and Treanor combined for 17 home runs during the 2010 campaign, while Vlad smacked nine dingers and hit .350 against the Gigantes in his career — oh, and accounted for 29 homers in 2010, which is 12 more than Murphy and Treanor combined. Then there’s Molina, who’s not only a fine hitter, but a player who actually knows the opposing rotation: having caught them for 61 games during the regular season. What the hell were these guys doing sitting on the bench? Or, put another way, Ron Washington’s failure didn’t come in the 8th inning of last night’s game, it came when he filled out the line-up card.


