Musial and Pujols
Thursday, February 17th, 2011Sixty-three years ago this month Stanley Frank Musial entered spring training to prepare for what would be his greatest season in baseball. That year, his seventh (he missed 1945 when he was in the Navy), he hit .376, had 131 RBI and a slugging percentage of .702. He was selected to the 1948 All Star squad and won MVP honors for the third time in his career. It was a performance that most pros only dream about.
Legend has it that Musial’s prowess on the field was matched by his modesty off it. In 1969 his baseball exploits were honored in Cooperstown. And earlier this week, the actions and demeanor of the simple kid from the Pennsylvania coal country were rewarded at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue when the President presented him with the Medal of Freedom. The remarks made about Musial, who was wearing his trademark Cardinal-red sports jacket, noted that he was receiving the award because his “humility and decency remain a model for all Americans to this day.” With apologies to Leo Durocher, it seems that sometimes nice guys do finish first.
Which brings me to Mr. Pujols — who’s greatest season was 60 years after Musial’s. In 2008 Albert hit .357 with 116 RBI and slugged .653, receiving an All Star and MVP nod as well. The comparison of the two seasons provides some awesome numbers: in 1948 Musial hit .376, slugged 39 home runs and drove in 131. Pujols numbers are nearly identical: .357, 37 HRs, 116 RBIs. You can claim that Musial’s 1948 numbers showed he outperformed Pujols’ 2008 numbers, but Pujols was walked more, and outdistanced Musial on OBP. But the two are itchy close — and both deserved the plaudets they gained. And they were nearly identical in age: Musial was 27 in 1948, Pujols was 28 in 2008. There’s a squeaky difference in the numbers, and sixty years of baseball history in between.
There are other comparisons. Pujols, like Musial, is known for his lunch box attitude toward the game. He prepares, puts on the spikes and plays hard but clean. No show-boating, no bragging, no bull. Perhaps in 60 years or so Albert will also be in the White House receiving medals for what seems to be an outdated idea: sportsmanship.
Yesterday, on “Mike and Mike in the Morning,” the question was raised: for what possible reason would the Cardinals even consider giving Pujols a 10-year deal for A-Rod money ( given that he’s 31 years old)? “Aren’t his best years behind him?” Mike Greenberg asked, incredulous at both the idea of the length of contract and amount of money being discussed. Well, probably. And I thought he had a point until I looked at what Musial did from age 32 to 41. During that span he averaged .313 at the plate (he hit .330 when he was 41), 88 RBIs per season and his OPS was .937.
Can Pujols do that? No one knows. But don’t forget, Albert’s got some fresh legs from playing first base all these years and he doesn’t get hurt. Are Musial’s numbers worth A-Rod’s salary? Maybe not. But they’re worth one hell of a lot. Add to that Pujol’s work ethic, leadership qualities and demeanor and those deserve, in my opinion, a premium. I don’t know what Pujols should get in terms of years or money, but the Cards would be absolutely crazy to let him get away. Don’t they know they have Stan Musial playing for them?


